msandhu wrote:Hi ,
I also have a few questions regarding this topic of members who are familiar with gun laws.
I have a relative who is living in US. He has a gun license in India ( with a retainer) and soon going to become citizen of US. He thinks that if he gets the US citizenship, he will have to surrender his license and his gun.
1) Does he needs to inform someone of his change of status in regards to Gun license in India ?
2) Will his changing of citizenship effects his license status in India ?
3) He is going to get OCI after citizenship. Will that help him in retaining his license ?
Regards
MSandhu
msandhu wrote:Hi Naga,
Thanks for your reply..but it raises one more question for him.. Since he is not physically living most part of year and visiting India like 1-2 months every year, will he still be considered resident of India or not ?
Regards
MSandhu
verminator wrote:Seriously though, is there anyone out there with first (or even second) hand knowledge of a foreigner receiving an arms licence? It ought for the sake of realism, to be someone without government connection and without great personal wealth or public status.
verminator wrote:Nagarifle
I have no doubt that a huge number of people in India give 'inducements' 'backhanders' and so on, to get the work done. You sound quite sensitive on the topic. Do you have some regretable experience to share?
verminator wrote:Nagarifle
I have no doubt that a huge number of people in India give 'inducements' 'backhanders' and so on, to get the work done. You sound quite sensitive on the topic. Do you have some regretable experience to share?
Whether or not the topic is 'moot' is hardly for you to decide, is it?
goodboy_mentor
Your point about presenting a 'savvy' front on applying is a good one. It introduces a healthy, counterbalance of fear to the clerk, perhaps thereby motivating him to actually perform his duty.
I suppose "Sport" is the way to go, unless you happen to live in a hotspot or work as a bodyguard. Difficult to argue we need a gun for self defence whilst living in a village where nobody else has a gun. So would you agree that "Sport" is the best reason to give?
I disagree, if you apply for "Sport" you are opening the door for questions like: Are you a member of any shooting club? If answer is no, then you are giving a very good reason for rejection of the application. If you are a member of any shooting club, then it makes sense to apply for "sport". "Self Protection" is a very valid and legal reason. It is not necessary that you need to live in a "trouble spot" or be under some "threat" to get a firearm license. An act of violent crime is random just like an accident, it can happen anytime, anywhere without any warning.I suppose "Sport" is the way to go, unless you happen to live in a hotspot or work as a bodyguard. Difficult to argue we need a gun for self defence whilst living in a village where nobody else has a gun. So would you agree that "Sport" is the best reason to give?
The applicant may seem slightly anomalous in context to a corrupt policeman who is asked to submit the "Police Report" because he might want to get some illegal "gratification" from the applicant. Please refer the judgment of Mr.justice M. Katju of Hon'ble High Court Allahabad:Although as I say, if one lives surrounded by unarmed neighbours, it still leaves the question in the mind of the officers: "So, why does THIS particular person need a gun for Self Defence" when nobody around him does? You must agree, it makes the applicant seem slightly anomolous in context. Being viewed as an oddity surely wouldn't help the cause:)
Please read details of judgment at: viewtopic.php?f=4&t=3366judgment of Mr. Justice M.Katju in CMWP No.4723 of 1993 (reported in AIR 1993 ALLAHABAD 291) wherein right to carry non-prohibited firearms is treated to be embedded in right to life, hence a Fundamental Right under article 21 of the Constitution of India; it is further ruled that Licence for non-prohibited arms is to be ordinarily allowed except in case of heinous offence.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests